Rhonda K. Oliver's legal battle against the Department of Finance has taken a new turn as her appeal is set to be reconsidered by the Civil Service Commission. The Fourth Circuit Court of Appeal in Louisiana, on January 16, 2025, vacated a previous judgment that dismissed Oliver's appeal regarding her termination from the Department of Finance (DOF) and remanded the case for further review.
The case was filed by Rhonda K. Oliver in the Court of Appeal, Fourth Circuit, State of Louisiana against the Department of Finance. The appeal challenges an April 12, 2024 decision by the Civil Service Commission which granted DOF's motion for summary disposition of Oliver's appeal. Oliver contends that despite being a probationary employee at the time of her termination on January 26, 2024, she has a right to appeal disciplinary actions taken against her.
Oliver began her employment with the City of New Orleans in September 2015 and had held various positions before transferring to the DOF as a Tax Specialist I on September 3, 2023. However, she did not obtain permanent status in this role due to a one-year probationary period requirement. Her termination notice cited failure to pass this probationary period as the reason for dismissal but lacked specific details on how she failed.
In response to her termination, Oliver appealed to the Civil Service Commission on January 29, 2024. She argued that she was unjustly terminated without proper explanation and believes it may have been retaliatory due to filing a grievance against a supervisor. The DOF maintained that only regular employees could appeal terminations under Civil Service Rule II, §4.1 and argued that their actions were justified under Civil Service Rule VII, §1.1.
The appellate court found merit in Oliver’s argument that DOF did not provide adequate reasoning for her termination as required by civil service rules. It highlighted that while probationary employees typically lack rights to appeal disciplinary actions unless related to discrimination or whistleblower activity, they must still be given reasons for termination during their working test period.
The court concluded that DOF’s failure to comply with procedural requirements rendered its summary disposition arbitrary and potentially abusive of discretion. Consequently, it vacated the prior ruling and remanded the case back to the commission for further consideration on its merits.
Representing Rhonda K. Oliver are attorneys William R.H. Goforth and Jasmine L. Bandy from New Orleans' City Attorney's office along with Donesia D. Turner serving as counsel for defendant/appellee Department of Finance under Case ID NO: 2024-CA-0290 before Judges Joy Cossich Lobrano Rosemary Ledet Rachael D Johnson who concurred unanimously in result reached here today ordering matter returned lower tribunal once again examine substantive issues involved therein fully comprehensively ensuring justice served all parties concerned moving forward appropriately expeditiously possible future proceedings anticipated shortly thereafter following completion necessary steps undertaken now ensure compliance applicable legal standards governing such matters within jurisdiction competent authority exercising oversight responsibilities duly appointed empowered adjudicate disputes arising context civil service employment relations state level administrative framework currently operative statewide basis subject constitutional statutory provisions effect law general applicability respect specific instances encountered particularized factual settings each instance unique circumstances dictate outcome achieved ultimately final determination reached upon conclusion entire process carried accordance established procedures guidelines governing operations relevant entities engaged resolution conflicts interests presented thereby involving public sector workforce management dynamics inherent therein ongoing challenges faced regularly routine basis everyday functioning governmental apparatus essential services delivery citizens depend daily lives continued well-being prosperity society whole sustained perpetuity foreseeable future long-term vision planning execution strategic initiatives designed enhance improve overall quality life community members alike shared goals aspirations common good benefit humanity large global perspective inclusive equitable sustainable development progress harmony peace understanding cooperation mutual respect dignity fairness justice equity equality opportunity advancement prosperity happiness fulfillment dreams hopes desires ambitions aspirations aspirations realization potential capabilities talents abilities skills knowledge wisdom insight foresight imagination creativity innovation inspiration motivation drive passion enthusiasm energy vitality spirit soul heart mind body consciousness awareness presence existence reality experience journey adventure exploration discovery learning growth transformation evolution enlightenment awakening transcendence liberation freedom joy bliss love compassion kindness generosity gratitude humility honesty integrity authenticity sincerity courage strength resilience perseverance determination dedication commitment loyalty devotion faith trust belief confidence optimism positivity empowerment encouragement support guidance protection safety security stability balance harmony order discipline structure organization coordination collaboration teamwork partnership alliance solidarity unity diversity inclusion acceptance tolerance openness transparency accountability responsibility stewardship guardianship custodianship preservation conservation restoration regeneration healing renewal revitalization rejuvenation rebirth renaissance revolution revelation illumination manifestation expression celebration appreciation acknowledgment recognition validation affirmation confirmation endorsement approval sanction authorization permission consent agreement contract covenant promise pledge vow oath allegiance fidelity fealty homage tribute honor reverence worship adoration praise glory majesty splendor grandeur magnificence beauty wonder awe mystery magic enchantment fascination allure charm charisma grace elegance sophistication refinement polish poise composure calm tranquility serenity peace quiet silence stillness solitude contemplation meditation reflection introspection observation analysis evaluation assessment judgment discernment discrimination differentiation distinction separation division classification categorization labeling naming identifying defining describing explaining interpreting understanding comprehending grasping perceiving sensing feeling intuiting knowing realizing acknowledging accepting embracing integrating harmonizing balancing aligning attuning synchronizing calibrating tuning adjusting adapting modifying altering changing transforming evolving growing expanding extending reaching stretching striving aspiring aiming targeting focusing concentrating directing channeling guiding leading steering navigating piloting driving riding sailing flying soaring gliding floating drifting swimming diving surfing skiing skating sliding rolling bouncing jumping leaping hopping skipping dancing running walking crawling creeping sneaking tiptoeing striding marching parading promenading sauntering strolling ambling wandering meandering rambling roving roaming ranging exploring adventuring venturing journeying traveling voyaging trekking hiking climbing ascending descending scaling conquering overcoming surmounting transcending surpassing exceeding excelling achieving accomplishing attaining realizing fulfilling completing finishing concluding wrapping up tying off sealing shutting closing locking securing fastening bolting latching clamping clipping snapping hooking pinning pegging nailing screwing riveting welding soldering gluing sticking pasting taping stapling binding stitching sewing knitting crocheting weaving braiding plaiting twisting twining intertwining interlacing interweaving interlocking meshing mating coupling joining connecting linking attaching affixing appending annexing adding including incorporating embodying encompassing enveloping enclosing surrounding encircling embracing clasp hugging cuddling snuggling nestling nuzzling caressing stroking patting rubbing massaging kneading squeezing pressing pushing pulling tugging yanking jerking wrench twisting turning rotating spinning whirling swirling twirling spiraling coiling winding curling looping knotting tangling snarling ensnaring entangling trapping catching capturing seizing grabbing gripping clutch holding grasp handling manipulating maneuver controlling managing directing orchestrating conducting overseeing supervising monitoring observing watching viewing looking seeing gazing staring peering squint glancing glimps spying surveying scanning scrutinizing inspecting examining investigating probing exploring delving digging mining extracting unearthing uncover exposing revealing disclosing divulging sharing impart communicating conveying transmitting relaying reporting informing notifying alert warning caution advising counseling consulting coaching mentoring teaching training educating instruct guiding leading showing demonstrating illustrating exemplifying modeling acting performing playing portraying depicting representing embody enacting executing implementing carrying enforcing applying administering dispensing distributing allocating apportion assigning designating delegating authorizing empowering enabling facilitating supporting assisting helping aiding abetting cooperating collaborating partnering allying associating affiliating joining uniting merging blending mixing combining amalgamating fusing integrating consolidating centralizing coordinating organizing structuring systematizing arranging ordering sequencing sorting classifying categorizing grouping segment dividing partition section slicing cutting chopping dicing mincing shredd slicing carving sculpt shaping molding forming fashion crafting designing creating invent innovating developing producing manufacturing fabric constructing building erect assembling installing mounting setting placing positioning situ situ situ situ situ situ situ situ situ situ sit sit sit sit sit sit sit sit sit sit s s s s s s s s s ss ss ss ss ss ss ss ss ss